Review: Whipping Star

whipping star

Dung Beetle

One dung Beetle
(1 out of 4 rating)

Audible, the dealer for my audiobook addiction, periodically has deep-discount science fiction sales. During one of the latest, I picked up two books by Frank Herbert, the author of Dune, which I’ve seen reported as the most-loved and the best-selling science fiction book ever. I read Dune when I was a kid, and seem to remember enjoying it, so I thought Herbert’s other books would be a safe choice. I’ve now learned that authors can be extremely variable in the quality of their work. My first clue should have been that I’d never heard of these books, even though they were written by such a big-name author. My second clue should have been the various book covers for Herbert’s non-Dune books: they usually feature his name in huge letters, with the name of the story below as an afterthought.

In the story, there’s this super-being (who is also a star, as in an actual astronomical object) who facilitates teleportation around the universe by humans and a bunch of alien races. It turns out that anyone who has used this teleportation (which includes everyone except for newborns) will die when the super-being dies. The super-being has signed a legal contract allowing it to be whipped to death. (Am I the only one who thinks the quality of super-beings is going downhill?) The main characters in the story are government agents hunting the villainess behind the contract/whippings.

The Spoiler Dragon

A large portion of the book involves conversations between the super-being and the main characters. These conversations take place via some kind of direct mind-to-mind connection, rather than in spoken words. So, it makes absolutely no sense when they continually get hung up on English words with multiple definitions. For instance, a character asks the super-being about the whippings, and gets a response like “whipping is the process of beating cream into a froth”. Are we supposed to believe the character got those two concepts confused in his mind? Also, for this story to work, the characters hundreds or thousands of years in the future have to speak the same form of English we used in 1970. I suppose if you’re the kind of person who finds puns hilarious, you might enjoy these conversations, but my finger was hovering over the delete button during all of them.

The idiocy of the book doesn’t end there. The government agents (remember, the guys out to save every human and alien life in the galaxy/universe) are always worried that some judge will issue an injunction against them, or that the villainess’ lawyers will take some interfering action. Here’s a plan for you, government agents: go to the evil lady’s lawyers, and explain to them that if her evil plan is carried out, they and all their loved ones will die. Now, her lawyers are working for you.

Along similar lines: one of the characters gets lost, but declines to have his homing beacon activated because it’s too expensive. Excuse me, highly competent government agent, as all sentient life is about to end in a matter of hours, perhaps this would be an appropriate time to trade money for time?

Didn’t at least one other person read this text before it was published? Maybe after Dune was so successful, they just took Whipping Star right off the author’s typewriter to the printing press. I drew upon my immense reserves of willpower and managed to finish the story, hoping a great ending could redeem it.

The Spoiler DragonThe Spoiler DragonThe Spoiler Dragon

It turned out that the whipping didn’t actually harm the super-being, the malicious intent was just hurting its feelings. All that the characters had to do to solve the crisis was tell the super-being that they loved it. That sounds so ridiculous that I’m starting to wonder if I just quit listening and made it up. No, I wouldn’t invent something that ridiculous. There was something near the end of the story where the characters shunted extra hydrogen gas into the star, but it was a temporary measure; a metaphorical group hug is what really saved the universe. So, the next time you’re faced with an alien invasion, robot uprising, zombie apocalypse, or carnivorous dinosaurs – just give them a big hug.


  1. Wow. I’m so sorry you had to endure that book. It’s hard to believe the author of Dune penned so many bad books. Even the sequels to Dune are pretty difficult to suffer through.

  2. It sounds very 1970s. Was it meant to be a comedy? Phnark. Cracking review, anyway. Thank you for reading it so I don’t have to.

    1. Comedy never occurred to me; if it is a comedy, it’s so subtle that I didn’t notice.

  3. Did Herbert actually write this, or is one of those ‘ghosted’ books that emerge years after the author has died?

    1. As far as I can tell, this book came out in 1970, five years after Dune, and more than a decade before the author’s death.

      1. Very odd. I’ve not read much Herbert, and not for years, but maybe he’s a Dan Brown on SF who got lucky with one idea but wasn’t that great as a stylist? Sometimes the concept catches and the writing comes a poor second. Dune was certainly a strong idea that could perhaps carry some ropey writing?

        1. I’ve heard it argued that Herbert really did hit one big idea almost impossibly big, something that neatly fit between John W Campbell-esque expectations and the then-exciting new-to-public-attention science of ecology, and that besides that lucky stroke (which was an almost unimaginable one, and shouldn’t be minimized) was otherwise an unremarkable writer. Of course, how many writers would be anything if you cut out their biggest claim to fame?

          1. Exactly – there’s no shame in it. Luck is everything in getting noticed, no matter how good or bad you are technically. I like a lot of writers who are ‘iffy’ and don’t get a lot of writers I know to be technically good, The cut comes, I guess, if you like a writers one big moment and then feel let down by the rest…

  4. Thanks for the warning!

  5. I love your rating system!

  6. Love to hear what you would make of ‘The Dosadi Experiment’ also by FH

  7. […] (Of course, this is the same website which had glowing reviews of “Whipping Star”, you can read my review to see my opinion of that.) I suspect that many literary types just aren’t comfortable with the […]

  8. […] penis! The Is Shop – pointlessly random – no logic to character behavior or physical events. Whipping Star – idiotic super-being – puns – lawyers facilitating end of sentient life – big hippie hug […]

  9. […] mention goes to Whipping Star, which came very close to taking the award. One commenter voted for New Beginnings after strongly […]

  10. I’m so excited to find your blog. Thanks for liking my canary carnage piece so I could discover you! I was preparing for writing a comment to this affect when I noticed this “Hall of Dung,” and cringed. I needed to make sure none of my blurbs were here. Fear make me click in and then – phew. I mean, if a guy like Frank Herbert can be “dung beetled,” I’d be okay with something of mine being here. Besides, I have to publish first, right??

    I’m already digging your site as a great resource. Thanks for blogging.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: